Tuesday, 1 May 2018

It's not always about rampant orgies, but it's actually OK if it is, too.

So SBS did a thing about open relationships: https://www.sbs.com.au/ondemand/video/1213134403843.

It's actually not too bad. Whilst they do get a little obsessed about how it works and who sleeps where, they did manage to avoid engaging in the sort of negative and abusive commentary that people on Facebook and Twitter later failed to refrain from. Although it appears they haven’t sunk to death and rape threats that tend to follow any feminist commentary online. Congratulations to the people brave enough to expose themselves to these trolls.

The general public do get focussed about sex and jealousy in open relationships; this is all the naughty and exciting stuff in people's minds. But what was only briefly mentioned in the show that I think is crucial in changing our of perspective on relationships is how forms of polyamory, open relationships or relationship anarchy are pragmatic and political. Talking about love, communication, respect, consideration, boundaries, scheduling and practicalities does a bit to help people see it's not all rampant orgies, but they really are important to any sort of relationship. Relationships are work. They are constant negotiation and consideration of another person. Pointing out that we do the same sorts of things in open relationships is only one step in getting people to question how and why our society became so attached to monogamy and how in most cases monogamy is really a myth.

Have any of the self-righteous proponents of monogamy had a look at modern relationship statistics? What people hold up as an ideal is far from the reality. Most relationships end and most relationships involve infidelity. I remain flabbergasted at the cognitive dissonance displayed by people getting married for the 2nd, 6th, 8th times, making yet another vow that they will be faithful to that person until death do they part. Given that lifelong monogamous relationships almost never happen, some form of open relationship is an honest, pragmatic way of having a relationship. If people are going to have affairs or leave someone for another, are we not better off talking about this stuff honestly and openly than hiding and lying? We have already diversified our ideas of how relationships have to look. Relationships can involve different permutations living together, childrearing, sharing finances, celebrations of commitment and being of different sexes. Why not diversify them to anything that any number of consenting adults agree them to be? What a relationship means and how it works are things that should be negotiated by the participants in it, not by society, law and religion. And before anyone carries on about animals, children or the harbour bridge, note I said "consenting adults".

Open relationships are also a political choice. Monogamy isn't "natural". How the hell are we do say what is natural, whilst writing on the Internet from the comfort of our houses, munching on processed food? We are so far removed from natural that it is impossible to say what it is anymore. However, we can observe a lot of social structures reinforcing monogamy. Religion, law, government agencies and patriarchy may have a little hand there. Normal everyday exposure to films, books, fairy tales and music lyrics continues to promote this vision of a "natural" relationship.  I get that people feel that it is natural, because it is all they have been told all their lives. Years of exposure to ideas and behaviours normalises them. But monogamy has always had exceptions for men. Polygyny, concubines, mistresses, prostitutes - these are ways in which society has accepted non monogamy for men, because men are supposedly more sexual beings. They have needs. They are unable to control them. Evolutionary psychology blethers on about how men want to sew their seeds as broadly as possible whilst women want to find one man to protect and provide for them. Blah blah blah. Monogamy is a form of control of women. It ensured ownership of women passed from father to husband, provided certainty of parentage for men to hand on their property. It perpetuated stories about women being less sexual beings whilst implementing a bunch of practices and laws to contain women's sexuality (FGM, chastity belts, treatments for ”hysteria”, burkas, witch hunts, honour killings, beheading and stoning “unfaithful” women, the list goes on … ).

And strangely enough, the rate of marriage breakdown has escalated with social and economic changes that enabled women's independence. When women are able to make choices to leave relationships they are not happy in, they do. 

The other political aspect of polyamory (in its most open guises at least) is it says that we have no right to control what our partners do with their bodies and emotions. Indeed, it's a bit hopeless pretending to do so at all. No amount of saying "you can only be attracted to me" or indeed telling yourself "I will only ever be attracted to this person from now on" is going to stop a basic physiological reaction. Controlling behaviour is unacceptable. Even though people are voluntarily entering into these unspoken agreements about relationships, they are part of spectrum of controlling behaviours that most of us will acknowledge are unacceptable. We have just chosen a place on that spectrum of what controlling behaviour is ok and what isn't. I don’t think it’s ok to tell someone who they can and can’t have sex with or what they are allowed to feel for other people. Jealousy isn’t a sign of love. It’s a sign of insecurity, entitlement, possessiveness, fear or unmet needs, all of which are issues that need to be addressed no matter what format your relationship takes.

I find people in polyamorous relationships tend talk about how it is all about love. There are parts that are about love. I'm happy to agree that we can love as any people as we damn well want, if we are lucky enough to meet those people at the right time and stages in all of our lives.   I find it challenging when we focus on the love side, however, because it tends to feed justifying lifestyle choices in the terms of the traditional morality of relationships. It makes our choices sound acceptable according to the terms of the critics. But it is also about sex. Because, let's face it, sex is fun. Dating is fun. We freely admit that we have sex for fun these days. We admit to finding other people attractive. Those of us born after 1968 grew up in a world that is much more accepting of serial relationships, premarital sex, casual sex, friends with benefits. Why do we still accept a prohibition on ever having sex with another person again? It’s not depraved to experience and act upon normal, healthy sexual desires. It’s not shameful. It’s not wrong. When we don’t talk about open relationships involving acceptance of sexuality, we continue to buy into the idea that feeling desire and attraction outside of limited contexts is wrong. Sexual practices can be anything any number of adults able to give consent freely choose to participate in. Plenty of people think those rampant orgies are fun too, and that's OK.

Our world moralises and controls sexuality, perpetuates stereotypes about men’s and women’s desires and needs, denies female sexual agency and men’s capacity for emotional expression and communication. Open relationships are a very pleasant change from the double standards of male and female sexuality we have been subjected to, where it is acknowledged that women too have desires and men have the capacity to feel emotions and communicate.

Wednesday, 9 November 2016

On flabbergasting victories of ignorance

Here we are after another flabbergasting victory to ignorance and I hear the explanation again that this is because people are disenchanted with the establishment. They want change, they want action, so on, so forth. So it was the British voted for Brexit, Australians voted in a bunch of raving nutter One Nation senators and now the US has voted in Trump. I’m sorry, but Trump is not anti-establishment. He is a rich, white, heterosexual male in a first world country. You don’t actually get much more establishment than that. Why do these results supposedly reflecting the people’s rejection of what is happening in our world all end up supporting conservatives? Le Pen, the National Front, Rise Up Australia and myriad other right wing unthinkers around the world have taken off. Call me cynical, but I think this is really reflective of the desire of straight, white and usually male people to return to the good ol’ days when they didn’t have to share power, space, respect and resources with everyone else. Thus the Brits voted to return to colonialism, Aussies to a daydream of the 1950s and, actually, I’m not sure what America voted for … the constitutional right to be an offensive, sexist, racist imbecile?


If people were genuinely sick of the current state of the world and powers that be, we should be seeing a surge towards parties and people that are striving towards environmental sustainability, equality, peace etc etc. Instead we are seeing the rise of a bunch people who don’t appear to have thought much further than their own arsehole and advocate ideas that appeal to some sort of nostalgic unreality in the already privileged and the not so well off but still reasonably privileged who somehow think that the less privileged are the source of their woes, not the more privileged.

Saturday, 29 August 2015

Winter escape 2015

Winter having hit Natimuk sometime in April this year, I had been counting down to our winter trip for about 6 weeks by the time we finally drove out of town. On the way north, we stopped to visit friends and family and everyone seemed to have sick children so courtesy of these harbingers of plagues, by the time we got to Frog, we both had horrible colds. What a start. It seemed like colds had hit the whole country simultaneously as people from Melbourne, Hobart, Nati and beyond converged on Frog with their own strain of virus, on top of half of Qld, so I was expecting it to morph into a superbug any moment.


Keep Left, 24
So much for the plan of a bit of mileage to get into the groove then hitting a few routes I had been saving for a brave day for about 15 years now. Instead, everything felt desperate. Normally, I disagree with the popular view that the grades are stiff at Frog, but as I dragged by sorry snuffly self up Infinity, it had never felt so hard. Ok, so this might be what is feel like for the masses. By the end of the week I had given up on getting any form anytime soon and decided to scope out some potential projects on a nice friendly top rope. Fat Mattress conveniently got us above Keep Left which turned out to be very cool, highly body tensiony thin layaways in a sharp groove up an arete that widened to a flared offwidth and remained desperate to the end. The gear would be pretty thin down low, so I was happy I hadn't tried it ground up. Then Blood Sweat and Tears set us up for a rope on Future Tense, which is pretty stunning climbing, although to be perfectly honest, probably isn't 26, maybe because it's now standardly done with out the poorly protected and rather contrived start. The odd poor lock and flared handjam intermingled with a lot of technical layaways to a goey finish of crimpers and gastons.


I started to feel a tad better and decided we really should give the big gear a workout. I had borrowed some extra 5s and 6s (thank you Andrew and Callum!) for the occasion and wandered up Castor and Pollox. Castor really involves no offwidthing, but is super nice climbing, and remarkably for Frog, good rock the whole way. Well, it would if it had an anchor on the ledge where the really climbing finishes instead of having to scramble up to Theory ledge. Pollox on the other hand, involves some serious earning of every millimetre. The initial flary crack went from fat hands to fat fists, not exactly a cruise for my small hands, then proceeded through steep ground of 4 and 5 camalot sized. I was in there and grunting. But it was great. Again, the rock was perfect but it might be one of the harder 20s at Frog.


Continuing with the theme, we moved onto Lord of the Flies the next day. This has to be the most underrated route I have ever done. All versions of the guide described it as a long worthless wide groove, but whoever started this rumour must have just been putting people off actually climbing it, because it was great. It's a stonker of a line to look at. The initial finger crack was beautiful locks, like an easier version of Yankee. From the stance above it, I pulled up the rack of big gear ready for this “long, worthless wide groove”. Armed with 4 3s, 4 4s, 4 5s and 3 6s, I launched up a steep hand to fist crack then into the groove. The rock continued to be as good as Frog ever gets, and the walls decorated with just enough face holds for it to be funky 3 dimensional bridging up until the last 2m, where some good old fashioned thrutching brings you to the tree you have been eyeing off for 20m wondering if it was actually getting any closer at all. 40m of sustained, varied climbing on good rock and it has a real anchor at the top. No idea why it has been disparaged all these years. You maybe don't need all that big gear … you could get away with out any 6s, but take all the 4s and 5s you can get your hands on.


Lord of the Flies and the rack Douglas took out of it.

Douglas had this brainwave to do Sabrasucker, then finish up Grandma's Tonic to Theory Ledge in order to get to Southern Comfort, another obscure route neither of us had done before. Grandma's Tonic deserves all the disparaging it gets. After a loose vegetated traverse, Douglas got to thrutch up a manky, filthy groove and arrived at the belay tree happy to be alive. Southern Comfort however turned out to be impeccable locking up a clean corner that was sadly all too short. If the route continued as for the first 10m, it would be another 3 star route. Sadly, the 10m of filthy Frog top out knocks off 2 of those stars. Another candidate for an anchor below the choss.


Finally by our last day, the dregs of the cold had passed and we cruised up Devil's and Conquistador in a manner more to be expected before flying out to Darwin for a 2 week walk in Kakadu. My lovely friend Kylie asked me to write a little something about it, so if you have more time to kill, you can find what turned out to be a not-so-little something here: http://outdoorsyodyssey.blogspot.com.au/2015/08/kakadu.html


A little taste of Kakadu

After nearly a week to recuperate hanging out in Darwin with Natasha and Dave, drinking coffee, champagne and eating tropical fruit, we returned to Brisbane motivated for another quick trip out to Frog to send Future Tense before heading further north. Coming from 30 degrees everyday, Frog seemed a little cold, and I was rugged up in my thermals and jacket whilst a bunch of Tasmanians ran around shirtless. Future Tense was still glorious, was quickly dispatched then I rewarded myself with a top rope on Badfinger. I know, toproping an offwidth is a strange reward … but it was right next door and easy to throw a rope on. I was rather put off leading it by the story of Dave Jones nearly shredding through his rope on the sharp edge of the crack when he came off it years ago. The Antarctic Vortex was just reaching Qld at this point and the Main Range had been covered in black clouds all day that were ominously creeping towards us. An unusual mix of laybacking with knee bars got me to the stance between fat sections and a chance to see the wider world again for a moment. Armageddon looked like it was just about to hit us. A wall of black was only 100m away and wild winds were increasing by the second. I buried myself back in the crack again and at the top was quite relieved that Douglas still wanted a lash at it so I didn't have to face the pendulum over to the anchor in the increasingly atmospheric conditions.


We headed north trying to outrun the Vortex. We failed. Coolum reached a whole of 19 and after 2 days of climbing in all day shade in sub 20 temperatures, we kept running. We weren't so inspired by Coolum anyway. Not at all because we could barely get up the 24s …. It is potentially funky, interesting climbing, but consistently horrible rock. It is either sharp or dusty and friable or slopey and with the friction of a bar of soap. Just as I as I was about to remark that it was also one of the ugliest locations I have climbed in for a while, some local youngsters turned up to do a photo shoot. Not a climbing one, a scantily clad young woman who must have been rather cold. I tactfully shut up.


Lady Musgrave Island
Conditions looked good for a trip out to the reef the next day so we zipped up to 1770 and splurged on the boat out to Lady Musgrave Island. For a touron trip, it was remarkably good and conditions were perfect – the sea flat as a tack, no wind and plenty of sun. You are pretty much left to do your own thing once you get out to the lagoon and we snorkelled for hours with loads of fish, coral, a few turtles and an octopus that got rather pissed off at us and flashed all his range of colours. The island itself is a coral cay covered in pinsonias forming a forest straight out of fantasy novels.


Northwards further and we were convinced Qld was broken. We stopped for the night near Rockhampton and there I was rugged up in my thermals and puffy jacket. Should we go out to Eungella? Nope, too cold, keep running. There's a lot of cattle and cane in Qld and it just seemed endless by the time we finally made it to Townsville but at last, it was actually warm. We set up camp at Alligator Creek, a lovely,  quiet campsite south of Townsville with heaps of shade, a swimming hole and a lot of voracious bush turkeys. Bush turkeys really bring home that dinosaurs didn't actually die out, they just evolved into birds. Had we thought about it clearly, we might not have stayed there as Frederick's Peak is northwest of Townsville. By the time you had driven there and walked up to the cliff, it was 2 hours travel each way.


Local climbers were very helpful and gave us plenty of info on finding the crag and that there was really nowhere safe to camp around the quality outskirts of Townsville. Burnt out wrecks of cars and burnout circles mark the drive into the crag. I had assumed that they were stolen cars, but was later told that one of them was a climber's car, left there while they camped at the cliff and torched in their absence.


The walk in. South Sentinel is the obvious central peak
It's enough of a walk into the crag if you have a high clearance 4wd. More of one with a standard 4wd and really quite a lot of one when you have a little red Mazda 323. We got it as far as we could and hoped it was sufficiently out of the way not to get gutted. It's about an hour with full packs from there to the crag, and most of that road was actually built by the enthusiastic local lads with a chainsaw and jackhammer. They have also carried a shitload of bolting gear up that hill over the years. Chris told us they'd bought 1000 bolts from China last year and were already running low. They really are keen developers. We got a lift in with them one day and left our car way out on the main road. On getting back to Chris's car, we realised our keys were in the pack left at the cliff, so Douglas got a bonus run up the hill. We got dropped off at our car just in time for the police to rock up, someone having reported it being abandoned, so much later and it could have been missing on us anyway.


The python I tried to step on
We'd had a car drama to sort out that first morning, so it was near 1pm when we started walking. Not prime time in the tropics to walk up a big hill. I nearly stepped onto a massive carpet python drinking from a puddle on the path. It didn't move. I guess it knew it was a bloody great big snake and nothing was really going to attack it. We got there in time to run up 2 routes and stashed our packs there. The next day we took the time to look around the crag a little bit more. We were at the South Sentinel, which is the most developed crag there. Citizen Arcane, a grade 27 overhanging crack, looked amazing. We wandered up Primosanity in order to put a top rope on it, and this turned out to be very good in its own right, varied and and funky climbing on solid rock. The top rope didn't turn out to be the best idea. 40 degree over hanging diagonal cracks are rather hard to get a top rope on and then rather hard to actually work from it once you have. The next day we discovered it was much easier ground up. I put my foot in my shoe and nearly squashed a lizard. At least in wasn't a scorpion. It obviously hadn't had a lot of love since the first ascent in 2012, with the start sporting a lot of bracken and dusty crozzly rock, but the top 2/3s were delicious. I gave the bracken a hair cut and a bit of traffic cleaned up the rock so by the time we sent it, it was in great condition. Unfortunately, I don't think the crag gets that much attention and virtually none of that attention goes to trad routes, so it might return to its previous state quite quickly.


Citizen Arcane, 27
It was one of those routes where Douglas and I may as well have been on different climbs. From the knee bar rest at half height, I am virtually completely in the crack and he was virtually completely on the face. But as we both loved it, it must be good either way. Douglas had been demonstrating an amazing ability to send on his warm up this trip, and nearly did so again with Citizen Arcane only to take a 10m whipper of the last move of the crux. I scored the second ascent then moved onto Townsvillians, 25. I think the locals thought I had strange taste in climbs, but they suited me well. Townsvillians starts up a 22 that is given 3 stars and I hated it. It was everything I dislike about some Nowra climbs – polished slopers and crimps a long way apart and the whole thing only 5 m long. However, the moment you left that into Townsvillians, it was awesome. Steep jugs with great knee bars and squishy rests until you cut loose at the lip on double hand jams. Or at least I did.

Cutting loose on double hand jams, just an everyday trick
Then we moved on the The Gommernator, a steep groove that was hard to read, but succumbed to lots of kneebars and 3d weirdness. Sadly, after the 7th bolt, the rock deteriorated, but the first 2/3rds were very very cool. I thought I'd quickly run up Steeling Time as it was not yet midday but got spooked going for the 4rd bolt. With a bit a faffing, I got a long draw on it and cruised to the top. So it was supposed to go easily 2nd attempt, when I managed to get my hand stuck behind my knee bar, nearly rip my fingernail off trying to wiggle it out, then pop for the hold above the lip, get my feet all muddled up and come off. Ok, 3rd shot, really no worries. So up I go again, managed to keep my knee free of my hand, pop for the hold, realised I have the wrong hand on it, swap them around, completely mangle the sequence but think there is no way I am going to do all this again and pull out all stops bellowing and reach the thank god jugs that are nevertheless disconcertingly poorly attached to the cliff. I had some seriously worked back muscles from that one.

Happy Douglas after sending Citizen Arcane,
his first 27 in many years just as he was thinking
he was too old to climb hard anymore

Yum yum double icecreams
All this walking up hill and climbing steep stuff was getting bloody exhausting. Fortunately Townsville has a few nice things to do on rest days. We'd zipped down to the Whitsundays to see my parents and snorkelled with the largest turtles I have ever seen. We ate a lot of ice cream at the Frosty Mango, a tropical fruit farm that makes their own ice cream. Honestly, I really needed 2 double ice creams each rest day to keep up this level of activity. Besides, who can resist mango, black sapote, paw paw, ginger, macadamia, dragonfruit, coconut, sapodilla …We swam in Crystal Creek, Douglas twitched at birds and I read trashy vampire novels. And old friend of Douglas's took us for a boat trip around Magnetic Island. We discovered the Riverway Lagoons, which you would think were part of the river that had been made safe from crocodiles, but they are actually outdoor pools. Still, they were free and surrounded by massive shady trees made for lounging around. As most Townsvillians thought it was way to cold to swim, being the depths of winter now, it was also very quiet. We tried to swim in the Strand rock pool – another amazing piece of free swimming architecture that allows for year round ocean swimming, but it was closed for maintenance. The cafe next to it did have 5 different sorts of cheesecake, so being unable to decide between Cointreau and Pina Colada, I had both.


Boat trip around Maggie with Ewan
After the first week, we'd given up on our pretty campsite at Alligator Creek and moved into the old farts caravan park at Black River. When googling camping on that side of Townsville, we'd been very impressed by the lack of child facilities and emphasis on quiet. Ok, so they did say they were an over 50s park, but we aren't that far off now, surely they'll let us in. When we rock up, they are also a bit worried that we have a tent. They don't normally have tents there. But they were very helpful and we were soon set up in the shadiest spot in the park. Someone asked us where our caravan was and Douglas told them we had a blow up one. Being the only people there without a caravan, we were also the only people using the kitchen and storing stuff in the fridge, so it all worked out very well. And driving to the crag was now a mere 15 minutes.


The local lads had been busy developing a new sector on the North Sentinel, so eventually, we committed to moving our stuff down from the South Sentinel and up to the North. We'd been assured the walk in was much less, but as we trudged up the very steep eroded dirt, it really didn't seem that way. Eventually, we pop out at the Fishbowl, a fairly small but steep cave with a 27 crack out it. We warmed up on a couple of easy routes outside the cave, the first of which, the quantity of rock on the ground reflected the quality of rock on the climb and the next Douglas said took him straight back to the old days at Kangaroo Point. Then we jumped on Calamity Clam, which might actually be a good route, but there's some scaly rock and seepage at the start, then a fingery move into the crack and my fingers are way too old for that shit. Once in the crack, there are some great knee bars but a distressing lack of jams, which is a bit disastrous for a weakling like myself as I tried desperately to climb on face holds. The top 2/3s of the route are actually cool, but it was too late in the trip to devote time to sending it, so we stripped the gear and trudged on down. It was quite a relief to think that we weren't going to slog up that bloody hill again ….


In general, Frederick's Peak is a pretty good crag. We did do a few easier routes, and the climbing was often interesting, but the rock a lot worse. I wouldn't bother going there unless you can climb steep 23+, at which point, there are some great routes. South Sentinel is definitely the better sector, with a lot more climbing and better warm up routes. It's also quite a pretty spot to hang out with lots of big trees overhanging the base of the cliff and plenty of shady stuff to choose from. The North Sentinel might be subject to a little bit of developer's hype. It's not a very pretty spot, with sparse vegetation, and the base of the crag is all scree. There's no shade once the sun comes round, which it starts doing before lunch. The easy routes are less than decidedly average, but if you can climb 27+ steep stuff, the cave does has some cool looking things.


Zombie wallabies of Magnetic Island
We were suffering rather badly from being at the bum end of a long road trip and treated ourselves to 3 rest days and a holiday house on Magnetic Island.On our boat trip earlier, we had stopped at Rocky Bay so Douglas could show off the routes he had put up there in 1999, and as I rack up beneath them now, he's commenting on how he would never have imagined having a girlfriend who wanted to come and repeat these routes. But really, how can I say no when you show me some overhanging granite cracks?


Sussing out Curlew 23
To be perfectly honest, the rock on Maggie is not that great. It's coarse, crumbly and has that weird soapiness that can make sea cliffs really slippery. Still, the actual climbing is great. There'd been some ongoing jokes about how I was going to downgrade all of Douglas's routes, which was not exactly what I was thinking of doing as I battled up Not Without Jase, 20. 90 degree corners that overhang with a ¾ camalot crack in them don't really look like a warm up and it didn't really feel like a warm up. I was about to slip off any moment for most of the route. I topped out pumped out of my brains and suggesting that might be me done for the day. Maybe we would be upgrading all of Douglas's routes …




After recuperating in the shade and downing a few coffee lollies for inspiration, I racked up again for Curlew, 23. Douglas had done the first ascent onsight, so the pressure was on to keep up. This wall is rather steep too, and after placing a high wire, I pulled on then stepped back off again to psych myself up a bit more. Committed this time, I motored up with sufficient decent locks and the odd hand jam to get me up to where the 22 zips off right. I was pretty pumped again, but the 22 finished up one of those horrible slab things, so onward up the crack was the only option. I roared and bellowed and managed to pull off a sharp layaway, the grit under my feet stayed attached to the rock and finding a good lock gave me enough encouragement to make another move to the final horizontal. Suddenly, none of my gear wanted to go in the crack. I threw in the red, the grey and finally the yellow alien, but each time I had left the preceding one overcammed in the best spot for the next size down, so eventually I clipped them all, warned Douglas they might all pop and reached left. Oh, the delights of soapy granite! Just what I want, a round, slippery lump. I desperately reach further and the horizontal narrows enough to get a jam in so I launch onto that, swing my feet around to the ramp coming in and pull up to a jug and a squishy rest where I can procrastinate for a moment, knowing the action is all over but not want to mess up the easier finish. I didn't really feel like downgrading that one after that almighty battle either.


Brudl 27
On the opposite side of the boulder is Brudl, 27. Fingers to off fingers and steeper still. I'm feeling completely trashed already, so we popped a nice top rope on it and proceed to have completely different experiences of the route. It starts up a thin crack which peters out, leaving you to move right onto another crack. The angle relents slightly towards the top but offers some dreadful looking off fingers. Douglas struggled up the top crack whilst I struggle on the initial crack and reaching across to the second one. But it is awesome and surely it will feel better the next day when I am not torched.


Snorkelling in Florence Bay






Surfing the net in bed the next morning, I discover a gelati bar in Arcardia. That's it, we have 15 minutes to the next bus to get me to gelati. They also turn out to do awesome pizzas and then full of coffee, pizza and custard gelati, we went for a snorkel in Geoffrey Bay. This was the best snorkelling we did on the island, with great coral cover and a few giant clams thrown in.


The rattly fingers section of Brudl
Hoping we were sufficiently refuelled, we headed back down to Brudl. We rapped gear into it and attempted to warm up on a few boulders and a dogging lap of the route. Then I psych up for a real go at it. I was channelling my inner Sharma, pulling of the first big move with a grunt, then setting up a hand jam in the horizontal from which I dynoed, screaming, to the what we were euphemistically calling the jug at the start of the second crack. The Sharma must have been powerful in me that day as I caught the jug, swung my feet around, clipped and thought I was back in more comfortable territory in the crack. Except off fingers locks don't feel that great when you are already pumped rather than pulling on off the rope. I put my left up, stepped up, stepped down, retreated to the jug, shook out. Put the left in again, gritted my teeth and pulled up, got the next rattly lock, wiggled and wiggled but couldn't get it to feel good enough to release my left hand. Retreat to the jug. Try right hand up first. Retreat. Eventually, I try and channel Sharma again, but maybe he's not so useful on cracks as the second lock blows and my power scream becomes falling scream. I was caned. I could barely pull on from the rope. How had the crack suddenly become so hard? Then I realise I was stepping up to early, and I could pretend I was actually taller for a moment and stretch out with my feet on the horizontal break. Then I only had to pull on one ring lock with dodgy feet, before some good locks and a thin hand. From there, I had it down fairly solidly and topped out without further dramas.


Douglas made short work of the start before cursing the rattly fingers. After going up and down innumerate times, he still didn't feel like he had a sequence. By now the route was coming into the sun, so we retired for a swim. Rocky Bay is the nudist beach on Maggie. What that mostly means is aging, portly men with full body tans perambulating solo around the beach. I would imagine they were getting some exercise, but they aren't really moving enough for that. Occasionally they paddle in the water, but fall short of actually swimming. I'm not sure what they made of the odd people climbing on the rocks. People are rumoured to peek with binoculars from the lookout above, but there wasn't much action worth peeking at.


Then we settled in for some Scrabble to while away the hours before the sun went off the route. Sadly, no amount of Scrabble seemed to be rejuvenating my forearms. Douglas had another go, not really trying and casually said “take” on a low piece so he could work out a more efficient clipping stance. Then he got back on, waltzed through the dyno, set his fingers in the crack and just pottered on up as if it had never bothered him. He climbed over the top then asked had he really just done that with the one sit? We supposed to head back to the mainland the next day and deliberated whether we should change plans to give the route another shot. Douglas thought there was also further important gelati and pizza to be had. We gave in, left the gear in and extended our stay.


Our final day on the island saw me still strangely tired. Common sense would suggest that 3 months of hard climbing will do that to you, but I remain infuriated by my body's inability to keep up with my desires. I got on the route and it felt terribly hard again. I sat around and grumbled about how I was too tired to climb anything anymore and we should just start going home. Douglas got on and battled through the off fingers until I thought he was going to make it. He was shaking, panting and making all the right noises when suddenly he was off the very last move to the best jam on the route.


Still grumpy about being tired, I tied in again. The first big move to a two knuckle flat top felt dicey as, but in the spirit of not really caring, I tried to keep holding it long enough to execute the hand swap into the shallow horizontal jam that I dynoed off. Then I was set up for the dyno and still on, so I thought I may as well jump for it. With another almighty scream, I reached the jug but only just. For a millisecond, there was the subconscious debate between trying to hold it or giving up and trying to hold won. Somehow, I held it and set up for the locks. The second ring lock felt terrible, but I wrenched into it further and reached up for the good lock. Then my hand just didn't want to find the thin hand jam above it. After wiggling it in twice failed to find the sweet spot, I had to just go with what I had and cranked on. The good jam appeared and I almost breathed a sigh of relief, except I was too pumped to feel secure on the final face hold. I tried to shake on the jam, but nothing was coming back, so with another wail I threw myself for the jam over the lip which provided a better position from which to procrastinate about not falling off the exit before committing to it and finding myself squatting on the top slab in disbelief. It took me half an hour to recover enough to feel excited about sending.


Douglas goes for it again and makes it through the worst locks. He's much more comfortable above gear than I am and has skipped a piece so I'm watching closely as he starts to wobble. From my poor vantage point under such a steep route, I see his arse start to fall away from the cliff and I step down and brace myself against flying up in the air but no weight comes on the rope. In the milliseconds it takes to process this, I look up again in horror expecting to see him falling to the ground when the rope starts tugging upwards. He's grabbed the gear and is desperately trying to pull up and clip. He sits on the rope and I attempt to put my heart back in my chest after my microtrauma. Being the proud first ascentionist, Douglas was quite happy to call that a day and we stripped the gear, went for a swim and made a bee line for gelati. And champagne. And fish burgers.


Eye of the Tiger Direct, 20
One final thing we had to do before leaving Townsville was a nostalgic trip to Mt Stuart for Douglas. We had a lazy morning and hit the crag at 1pm just as it comes into the shade. As it also had a howling gale, I was rather wishing we had got there in the sun. We wandered up a couple of cracks at the Playground. The rock leaves a little to be desired, although the climbing was quite fun. Sort of like doing 1 star moderates at Frog. and I was rapidly quite excited about doing a few more. I have a problem. Just one more day before we really have to go home … We head back to camp debating if we have time. Eventually, common sense prevails. We are still trashed, Douglas's fingers hurt and only a week until my flight out of the Gold Coast.


Big Bend campsite
Boowinda Gorge

Taking the inland road down, we stop at Carnarvon Gorge for an overnight walk. It's cold in central Queensland. We might have ruined our ability to ever spend winter in Victoria again. Despite managing to organise a 2 week walk in Kakadu, somehow we manage to fumble a little overnight jaunt up a superhighway. We're about 20 minutes in when I ask Douglas if he'd grabbed the coffee. Oops. Oh well, tea and coffee lollies would suffice. A little further on, we realise we've forgotten a pot as well. Dinner became the crackers and cheese intended for lunch the next day and we'd just have to make it back to the car by lunchtime. The gorge is beautiful, but when you have been spoilt by off track wandering, somehow it's not the same traipsing up a path knowing you are going to find something good at the end of it, liberally decorated by placards and other walkers. We did see platypus and an echidna train. Horny echidnas are so focussed on their purpose they almost walk into you and over your rucksack. We were quite hoping for another party to be camping so we could borrow a pot. For once, we were disappointed to find ourselves alone and when another group did turn up at dusk, they didn't have any cooking gear with them at all. Crackers and cheese for dinner it was.
Echidna seeks sex

For a finale, we stopped back at Frog to do Deliverance. I figured a stronger day was unlikely to occur, and brave days never really occur, so this was as good as it gets. Douglas was still trashed, but like a dedicated climbing boyfriend, he came down to belay. Being the wuss that I am, I zipped over whilst cleaning Devil's Dihedral and whacked in some high gear to protect rather exciting looking start. The corner is ridiculously smooth low down, the crack fused except for spaced pin scars, which started off good before becoming bad and ending worse. I made it to my preplaced gear at the worst pin scar without too much drama, then got flummoxed. There was nothing on the face. The lock was bad and super painful. Above it, a pod opened up that would become the recessed twin cracks shortly, but right now offered the worst flared fist jam I have ever had the displeasure to try and pull on. I wedged my feet in the fused corner which was slightly more frictional than ice, cranked into a weird bum wedge then pushed into bridging on more ice in an attempt to reach the tantalising opening at the top of the pod. The feet went and so did I. In a vague attempt at salvaging the ascent, I lowered off, stuffed down some coffee lollies and went up again. This time I pulled it off and wedged into the twin cracks with relief. I really didn't want to fall off the rest of the route simply because I didn't want to have to repeat that start again. It hurt.


The middle section is easier but pretty odd climbing. Or at least it is for me. I don't know if normal people climb it with hands crossed into the opposite side crack to jam, or wedge a leg into the opening between the cracks like an offwidth or knee bar and chimney between the left wall and right crack, but it all worked well for me. Under the first roof, I reached up and placed some microcams as high as I could reach, then wiggled into as high a bridge as I could underneath it and just reached a hold that proceeded to moult on me. Reassuring. Warning Douglas, I committed to it anyway and soon found myself under the final roof. This one took a slightly chunkier green alien and I pulled through on good locks only to find myself desperately trying to get my feet over the lip in order to reach past the fused section towards some face holds. Eventually I admitted my foot wasn't going to make it and threw a knee at the left wall and bridged onto that inelegantly. Thus I could reach up for what turned out to be a non hold. I slapped frantically around to no avail and found myself dangling on the end of the rope contemplating I would have to do that painful start again now. Pulling on again, I sorted my feet rather than knees onto the rock and discovered something better resembling a hold further up and with only a little whimpering crawled over the top. I was wrecked. I was down skin on my hands, knuckles, knee and shoulder. I hurt everywhere I even thought about moving. We left the gear in and retired for chai and cheesecake.


Overnight, it pissed down. Really pissed down. It was the first rain we'd seen in 3 months. I got up in the night and walked straight into a puddle surrounding the tent. Fog, dampness and soreness delayed any thought of climbing in the morning and we went out for coffee thinking we might have a little abseiling excursion to retrieve the gear later. The sun did seem to want to come out and the ground was drying so soon only soreness was remaining as an excuse. Still, it was the last chance to do anything for the trip, so we headed down. A few laps on Gladiator seemed to kickstart the sore muscles and I roped up for Deliverance with the power of complete lack of expectation. The first bits of gear were wet. I cleaned a bit of grot that had washed down the corner overnight. Conditions were not looking good, but somehow it seemed more frictional and less painful than yesterday. Or maybe I was just numb. Actually, it was probably not carrying gear for 45m of climbing. But I found myself at the twin cracks without drama and suddenly the expectation level went up. Then I was under the final roof again, reminding myself where the holds had been and pulled up on the locks. The expectation level was sky high now. I got my feet up and cranked the final lock down, not quite reaching the hold as I felt it slipping. I wrenched those fingers harder in that crack, I was not slipping out of this now and cranked again, getting my tips over the hold, then walking them onto it properly, pushed out on the left wall to get my foot out wide and I was above the lip. Not the glorious onsight I had hoped for but nevertheless, a pretty good ending to the trip.  

Thursday, 14 May 2015

Is the PPL debate missing something?

I know it's not very PC of me as a feminist to question paid parental leave, but I do wonder about government provision of it. When a worker gets sick, who pays for sick leave? The employer.  When their mother dies, who pays compassionate leave? The employer. When their son goes into hospital, who pays family leave? The employer. So why is it a government responsibility to provide parental leave, not an employer responsibility? Is it not reasonable to expect employers to provide a minimum parental leave in the same way as they have to provide sick leave, annual leave, long service leave?

When parental leave is provided by the government, I think it moves from being a workplace right to a welfare payment. Which in itself is problematic - do we want family leave to be a worker's right or a welfare payment? And since when have welfare payments been either the equivalent of the minimum wage or an actual wage replacement?  Why is parental leave paid by the government not paid at the rate of other income support? I don't really have a problem with a welfare based parental payment either, but what we have is some weird combination of employment conditions and welfare provision. Does sickness allowance get paid at the minumum wage or wage replacement? No. Why not? If one is sick for months but has a job to return to, is it not a very similar position to be in?

Of course, everyone talks about paid parental leave being good for women. Which is sort of is, but it sort of isn't. It's only good for women because women continue to be the primary carers. And despite the occasional non gendered language such as I am stubbornly sticking to, that it is regularly referred to as maternal leave. Saying it benefits mothers is freely admitting that women are expected to continue to be the primary carers. And nothing about these policies is going to change that. Until we address the underlying social issues and assumptions that lead to women doing more than their fair share of the caring work, no amount of "parental leave" will change this situation. It just continues to admit that women care for babies despite clear evidence that babies can bond and be cared for by a whole range of people as long as their are available, loving and responsive to the baby's needs. Saying fathers can't do that is a mix of sentencing women to do the work, excusing men from it and underestimating men's capacities.

Why are family measures in budgets always "good for women"? If we didn't have the dreary expectation that it is women doing the work in families, family benefits would be good for, well, families ... Whilst the current reality sadly is that women do most of the work in families, I don't think it challenges that idea to continually focus on family business as women's business. Women can, should and do have many other aspects to their lives, and strangely enough, quite a lot of them don't involve families. Some women are too young to have them. Have not decided when or if to have them. Have been unable to have them. Chose not to have them. Have been there done that. Have them, but they are not the major source of issues in their lives. So really, when we talk about them being good for women, they are really only good for certain women at certain times of their lives in the current state of labour division. I'm not sure how good that really is.

Tuesday, 12 May 2015

Carrot or the stick? Or maybe just plain old fashioned assistance?

The budget papers suggest the govt is going to save $500 million dollars in child care benefits from it no jab/no pay policy. Well, now we know it's got nothing to do with increasing immunisation rates then.  If they thought the policy would actually increase immunisation rates, they would expect to still be paying the child care benefits. And in all honesty, they are probably right. Because how are you going to convince a bunch of people concerned about whether immunisation is all a big pharma/government conspiracy to immunise their children by trying to force them? Any sensible person would expect a knee jerk reaction of, "See it really is a conspiracy. They probably have microchips in the vaccines to keep track of everyone in the future".

Children who aren't vaccinated fall into those in families with socioeconomic problems such that they fall through the maternal and child health system and miss a lot a care as a result. Or those who come from countries where routine vaccinations just didn't happen. Or those who have deeply held, if misinformed, health/social/political concerns with vaccination. Are any of these going to be converted by the no jab/no pay policy? Probably not. The first two groups need intensive support to address the issues that have lead to them missing our on vaccinations and the third need to be provided with information in a non-aggressive manner and their concerns listened to respectfully and addressed appropriately. Of course, if you are going to consider religious objection to be a valid reason to not vaccinate, I don't quite see how other philosophical, non-scientific objection are any different.

But now we see that the government never really intended this to be a policy to address vaccination rates, but a way to save money on childcare benefits. Real action would provide further funding to access and support the families that need care. Carrots don't reach them through the complexities of their lives and sticks just put them further behind, whilst those holding "conscientious objections" tend to be well off enough to not be swayed by either.

Wednesday, 29 April 2015

Today seems like as good a day as any to withdraw our ambassador from the USA.

Today seems like as good a day as any to withdraw our ambassador from the USA. And China. Saudi Arabia. Singapore. Quite a few places really. While we are at it, maybe we should kick out all ambassadors to Australia from any countries that do follow international law and human rights treaties and save those countries the trouble of following Tony's new found ethical example.

Tuesday, 7 April 2015

Who needs sleep anyway? #penaltyrates

Oh those poor multinational companies paying penalty rates. I know running a small cafe can be a marginal business, but when we hear all this carry on about penalty rates, this is the only sort of business we hear about. No one mentions McDonalds, Starbucks, Shell or Coles. Or pubs, hotels and casinos. There are plenty of big players in the hospitality industry as well. Is it my cynicism that these are the drivers of the campaign against penalty rates, not small town cafes? Of course, it doesn't look so good to say a multi-billion dollar company has the shits with paying its lowly employees something in compensation for not having normal free time.

Shift work sucks. I have done it for many years in a variety of fields, and it is something to be tolerated not enjoyed. We pay more for evenings, nights and weekends, because these are the times people normally get together, relax, play sport and not the least, sleep. When do we have family dinners, birthday parties, BBQs, festivals, dance parties, weddings, sporting matches or just casual get togethers? It's very rarely at 2pm on Tuesday afternoon. When your friends or partner work normal hours, shift work is a sure fire way to minimise the amount of time you get to spend together. If you have kids, it's a sure fire way to reduce the amount of time you spend with them. It stuffs with your sleeping and eating patterns and has been shown to be detrimental to physical and emotional health.

If a night club objects to paying penalty rates, they could try opening on Tuesday at 2pm instead. I mean, it won't cost them as much. But then again, they might not get a lot of business. Some businesses just are suited to running out of normal business hours, and the price of running one is paying people to work out of normal business hours. It's not like these businesses went into it blind, it's been the case for 100 years.

These days, I'm a nurse. I hate working nights. I don't want to work nights, Tony, do you think the patients' families could just come in and look after them from 11pm so I could just go home to bed? Really, I don't think I am paid anywhere near enough to be desperately trying to go to sleep at 4pm in order to be awake all night then manage to get a few hours sleep in the morning before wandering around like a zombie until it all repeats again the next night. $67.70. That's it. A flat $67.70 night shift allowance for all that suffering. That's a 20% penalty rate. To work all bloody night.

But even if they were willing, neither Tony nor the patients' families could actually look after the patients safely, so I accept that much as I hate it, I will have to work nights. Someone needs to. And that is a basic fact of a lot of shift work. We aren't just talking about being able to get a coffee on a public holiday (and what is stopping these cafes from charging a public holiday surcharge if they are struggling so bloody much anyway?).  We are talking about nurses, doctors, carers, welfare workers, ambos, police, firepeople. And other unromantic jobs like cleaners, shelf packers and checkout operators. We all rely on someone doing this work. Strangely enough, only one of those jobs is renowned for its good income and even then, those doctors doing shift work aren't usually high in their pay spectrum. But it's ok to campaign to pay even less to these people already at the low end of income in Australia.

I've got this great idea. How much more productive could we be if all jobs were 24 hours? We could employ more people, get more things done ... look if all jobs were 24 hours, then we wouldn't have this strange prioritising of certain days over others or this expectation that we could actually sleep at night and we could just pay everyone the same rate for whenever. When Tony and the president of ACCI are awake at 3 am Saturday because they have to work, not because they choose to be out partying, then they can let us know what they think of penalty rates.